Chimi RentalAI property management
← The rental playbook

Chapter 3

Applicant Screening

Written criteria, what we verify, how we choose between applicants, and how we say no.

Key takeaways

  • Write your criteria down before the first showing, publish them, and never make an exception you wouldn't make for everyone.
  • Income is for the whole household combined: at least 3× the monthly rent.
  • Verify, don't trust: call the previous landlord (not just the current one) and the employer.
  • When two applicants both qualify, the earlier complete application wins. It's simple, fair and easy to explain.
  • If you deny someone because of their credit report, federal law requires an adverse action notice.

Our written criteria

Every applicant gets these in writing before they apply: in the listing, in the showing confirmation, and in the Rental Criteria download. Change the numbers to fit your market, but keep them written and keep them the same for everyone.

An application can be denied for:

  • Combined income of all applicants under 3× the monthly rent
  • An average credit score below 580 across the applicants
  • An eviction or broken lease in the last year
  • Money still owed to a previous landlord
  • Multiple collection accounts
  • A bounced check written in the last three years
  • False or incomplete information on any application
  • Moving in with more than two pets (assistance animals are not pets)
  • Criminal history that poses a demonstrable risk to residents or property (see below)

Who applies: every adult (18+) who will live in the home fills out an application and pays the screening fee.

Occupancy: our standard is two people per bedroom (a 3-bedroom house is up to six people). Don't go stricter than that without checking local codes: occupancy limits that are too strict can be familial-status discrimination.

Criminal history: blanket "no felonies" rules can violate fair housing law. Look only at convictions (not arrests), consider how serious the offense was and how long ago it happened, and apply the same rule to everyone. HUD's guidance on criminal records is worth reading before you write this criterion. Some cities restrict it further.

What we don't screen on: anything about a protected class: race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status, disability, plus anything your state or city adds (source of income, sexual orientation, gender identity, age, military status and others are protected in many places). Don't ask, don't search social media for it, don't note it. Ask everyone the same questions and decide on the written criteria alone.

What we check

Applications go through our property-management app, which runs the credit and background check (about $35 per adult, paid by the applicant). Each application packet should include:

  • Photo ID for each adult
  • Proof of income: the three most recent pay stubs, an offer letter, benefits or award letters, or tax returns for self-employment
  • Three months of bank statements
  • Rental history for the last two to three years

Then we verify:

1. Income. Pay stubs should match the bank deposits. For self-employed applicants, look at a year of statements, not one good month.

2. Previous landlord. Call the previous landlord, not only the current one. A current landlord who wants a problem tenant gone may give a glowing reference. Confirm the address and dates, that the applicant was on the lease, the rent, and whether it was paid on time. Ask about complaints, pets, notice given, the condition of the home at move-out, and the most useful question: would you rent to them again? The Verification Call Scripts download has the full list.

3. Employer. Confirm employment, start date, full or part time, position and pay. Many employers will only confirm dates and title; that's fine.

4. Credit and background. Look for evictions, landlord collections and judgments, and the overall pattern of payments, not just the score.

Log everything in the application record as you go. By the time you make a decision you should have, for each adult: contact details, ID, income documents, credit check, background check and landlord reference.

Choosing between applicants

  1. Drop any application that doesn't meet the written criteria.
  2. Of the ones that do, the earliest complete application wins: all adults applied, all documents uploaded, fee paid. Not the one who seems nicest, and not the highest income. This rule is easy to explain, easy to defend, and it rewards people who move quickly.
  3. Decide within two business days of the application being complete. Good applicants are applying elsewhere too.

Saying yes

Call the approved applicant first. It's good news and they'll remember the call. Then send the approval email from the Application Decision Letters download, and go to Tenant Setup and Move-In.

Don't reject the runner-up until the approved applicant has signed the lease and paid. Tell the runner-up honestly that someone else is ahead of them and you'll know within a few days.

Saying no

Every applicant who isn't chosen gets a written answer within a few days. Keep it short and factual, and give the real reason:

  • Another applicant who also qualified applied earlier.
  • The household income didn't meet three times the rent.
  • The average credit score didn't meet our minimum.
  • Something in the background check didn't meet our written criteria.

If any part of the decision was based on the credit or background report, including approving someone only with a larger deposit, the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act requires an adverse action notice. It must name the screening company, say that the company didn't make the decision, and tell the applicant they can get a free copy of their report and dispute anything inaccurate. The rejection letter in the downloads includes this wording. Most screening services also send one automatically; check that yours does.

Keep all applications, reports and notes, including the ones you denied, for at least two years (longer if your state requires it). If someone ever claims discrimination, those records are your evidence.

Downloads for this chapter

Editable Word files and PDFs. Fill in the [brackets], and check them against your own state's law before you use them.

  • Rental Qualification Criteria

    A one-page written screening policy to give every applicant before they apply. Edit the numbers, keep the consistency.

  • Landlord and Employer Verification Scripts

    The questions we ask a previous landlord and an employer when verifying a rental application.

  • Approval and Denial Letters

    The conditional-approval email with move-in steps, and a denial letter that includes the federal adverse action notice.

This is our own process, shared as-is and without warranty. It isn't legal, tax or financial advice. Laws differ by state and city and change often, and anything marked Arizona / Tucson only applies there. If you use any of it, you're responsible for how you use it. Check your own law, and have a local attorney review anything that affects a tenancy or money. Read the full note.