Chimi RentalAI property management
← The rental playbook

Chapter 8

Lease Renewal and Rent Increases

Keeping good tenants: when to start, how we structure renewal offers, the conversation, and raising rent to market.

Key takeaways

  • Start the renewal conversation 60–90 days before the lease ends, not 30.
  • Give options: a bigger increase for one year, a smaller one for two or three. Tenants who choose for themselves tend to stay.
  • Lead with thanks. Renewal is a conversation with someone who's been paying you, not a bill.
  • Raise rent to market gradually, with the data in hand. Losing a good tenant usually costs more than the increase.
  • No answer? Follow up on a set date, and know in advance what happens if they don't renew.

Timeline

WhenWhat
90 days before the lease endsCheck the tenant's payment history and the house's condition (from the last inspection). Pull market rents. Decide the offer.
60–90 days beforeThe renewal conversation. Phone first, then the same options in writing.
A few days afterFollow up if there's no answer.
Decision madeSend the renewal (lease extension) for e-signature. Update the rent charges once everyone has signed.
No renewalSchedule the move-out (see Move-Out and the Security Deposit) and start marketing (see Prepare the House for Rent).

Check what your lease says about notice. Many leases go month-to-month, often at a higher rent, if neither side gives notice. Some states require written notice of a rent increase a set number of days in advance.

Building the offer

Our default: a modest increase each renewal, discounted for a longer commitment. The longer they commit, the smaller the increase. For example:

TermIncrease
1 year$50 / month
2 years$30 / month
3 years$20 / month
4 years$10 / month

Adjust for the tenant and the market:

  • A great tenant (pays on time, cares for the house): lean toward the smaller numbers. They're worth more than the increase.
  • Under market by a lot: move toward market over two or three renewals instead of all at once (see below).
  • Over market: hold the rent flat. A small increase can push a good tenant to look around.
  • Pet rent stays as is unless the pets changed.

The conversation

Use the Lease Renewal Scripts download. The shape of it:

  1. Ask for a time to talk. "Do you have a few minutes this week? I'd like to talk about renewing your lease."
  2. Lead with thanks. Be specific: they keep the house in great shape, they always pay on time, they report problems early.
  3. Say you'd like them to stay, then give the options.
  4. Don't ask for an answer on the call. "Talk it over at home, and let me know by [date]. I'll text you the options so you have them."
  5. Send the recap the same day, in writing, with the exact options and the decision date.
  6. Follow up on the date if you haven't heard back.

If they push back on the price, listen. If you have room, come back once with a better number tied to a longer term ("For a two-year lease, the best I can do is ___"), and say it's your best offer. Then stop negotiating.

If they're not renewing, mention the referral bonus: if they refer an applicant who qualifies and signs before they leave, they get a credit on their last month's rent.

Signing the renewal

  1. Send the lease extension for e-signature. It states the original lease date, the new term, the new rent and pet rent, and that all other terms stay the same. Landlord signs first, then every adult tenant.
  2. Check that everyone has signed. Don't assume it's done because you sent it.
  3. Save the signed copy to the tenant's folder, with the date in the file name.
  4. Update the recurring rent charges for the new term, and confirm the first new charge looks right in the tenant's ledger.
  5. Set the next renewal reminder on the calendar.

Raising rent to market

When a home is far under market (typical for inherited tenants), do it in the open:

  1. Show the data. Print a Rentometer report or three comparable listings for the same bed and bath count nearby.
  2. Explain plainly. "You're paying $X. Similar homes nearby rent for about $Y. We need to get closer to that."
  3. Offer choices, for example:
    • a bigger step to near market, with a one-year lease and an improvement they'll value (new AC, new appliances, fencing, landscaping); or
    • a smaller step now on a shorter lease, with another step at the next renewal.
  4. Give them time, with a decision date, and send the options in writing.

Raising in two steps, with something given back, keeps far more good tenants than one big jump does.

Downloads for this chapter

Editable Word files and PDFs. Fill in the [brackets], and check them against your own state's law before you use them.

  • Lease Renewal Scripts

    The renewal call, the written recap, the follow-up, a one-time counteroffer, the referral offer, and the rent-to-market conversation.

This is our own process, shared as-is and without warranty. It isn't legal, tax or financial advice. Laws differ by state and city and change often, and anything marked Arizona / Tucson only applies there. If you use any of it, you're responsible for how you use it. Check your own law, and have a local attorney review anything that affects a tenancy or money. Read the full note.