Chapter 8
Lease Renewal and Rent Increases
Keeping good tenants: when to start, how we structure renewal offers, the conversation, and raising rent to market.
Key takeaways
- Start the renewal conversation 60–90 days before the lease ends, not 30.
- Give options: a bigger increase for one year, a smaller one for two or three. Tenants who choose for themselves tend to stay.
- Lead with thanks. Renewal is a conversation with someone who's been paying you, not a bill.
- Raise rent to market gradually, with the data in hand. Losing a good tenant usually costs more than the increase.
- No answer? Follow up on a set date, and know in advance what happens if they don't renew.
Timeline
| When | What |
|---|---|
| 90 days before the lease ends | Check the tenant's payment history and the house's condition (from the last inspection). Pull market rents. Decide the offer. |
| 60–90 days before | The renewal conversation. Phone first, then the same options in writing. |
| A few days after | Follow up if there's no answer. |
| Decision made | Send the renewal (lease extension) for e-signature. Update the rent charges once everyone has signed. |
| No renewal | Schedule the move-out (see Move-Out and the Security Deposit) and start marketing (see Prepare the House for Rent). |
Check what your lease says about notice. Many leases go month-to-month, often at a higher rent, if neither side gives notice. Some states require written notice of a rent increase a set number of days in advance.
Building the offer
Our default: a modest increase each renewal, discounted for a longer commitment. The longer they commit, the smaller the increase. For example:
| Term | Increase |
|---|---|
| 1 year | $50 / month |
| 2 years | $30 / month |
| 3 years | $20 / month |
| 4 years | $10 / month |
Adjust for the tenant and the market:
- A great tenant (pays on time, cares for the house): lean toward the smaller numbers. They're worth more than the increase.
- Under market by a lot: move toward market over two or three renewals instead of all at once (see below).
- Over market: hold the rent flat. A small increase can push a good tenant to look around.
- Pet rent stays as is unless the pets changed.
The conversation
Use the Lease Renewal Scripts download. The shape of it:
- Ask for a time to talk. "Do you have a few minutes this week? I'd like to talk about renewing your lease."
- Lead with thanks. Be specific: they keep the house in great shape, they always pay on time, they report problems early.
- Say you'd like them to stay, then give the options.
- Don't ask for an answer on the call. "Talk it over at home, and let me know by [date]. I'll text you the options so you have them."
- Send the recap the same day, in writing, with the exact options and the decision date.
- Follow up on the date if you haven't heard back.
If they push back on the price, listen. If you have room, come back once with a better number tied to a longer term ("For a two-year lease, the best I can do is ___"), and say it's your best offer. Then stop negotiating.
If they're not renewing, mention the referral bonus: if they refer an applicant who qualifies and signs before they leave, they get a credit on their last month's rent.
Signing the renewal
- Send the lease extension for e-signature. It states the original lease date, the new term, the new rent and pet rent, and that all other terms stay the same. Landlord signs first, then every adult tenant.
- Check that everyone has signed. Don't assume it's done because you sent it.
- Save the signed copy to the tenant's folder, with the date in the file name.
- Update the recurring rent charges for the new term, and confirm the first new charge looks right in the tenant's ledger.
- Set the next renewal reminder on the calendar.
Raising rent to market
When a home is far under market (typical for inherited tenants), do it in the open:
- Show the data. Print a Rentometer report or three comparable listings for the same bed and bath count nearby.
- Explain plainly. "You're paying $X. Similar homes nearby rent for about $Y. We need to get closer to that."
- Offer choices, for example:
- a bigger step to near market, with a one-year lease and an improvement they'll value (new AC, new appliances, fencing, landscaping); or
- a smaller step now on a shorter lease, with another step at the next renewal.
- Give them time, with a decision date, and send the options in writing.
Raising in two steps, with something given back, keeps far more good tenants than one big jump does.