Chapter 1
Prepare the House for Rent
Turning a house over between tenants, setting the rent, and getting a listing ready.
Key takeaways
- Start the turnover the day the old tenant's notice arrives, not the day they leave.
- Rekey between every tenancy. It's cheap and it's the first thing a new tenant will ask about.
- Price at fair market minus $50–$100. Aim for at least two qualified applicants to choose from.
- No good applicants after two weeks? Lower the rent. Don't wait it out.
- Photograph everything before move-in. Those photos settle deposit disputes a year later.
Timeline
| When | What |
|---|---|
| Notice to vacate arrives (or you decide not to renew) | Book the move-out inspection, line up cleaners and vendors, set the rent, start the listing draft |
| About 2–4 weeks before the lease ends | Listing goes live; showings start with proper notice to the current tenant |
| Move-out day | Move-out inspection (see Move-Out and the Security Deposit) |
| Move-out + 1 to 7 days | Make-ready work, cleaning, rekey, final photos |
| Before keys go to the new tenant | Walk the house against the make-ready checklist one last time |
The goal is zero empty days. That only happens if the work starts before the old tenant leaves.
Make-ready checklist
Walk the whole house with the Make-Ready Checklist download. The short version:
Systems and safety
- Test every smoke detector and carbon monoxide detector. Replace batteries; replace any detector past its date.
- Run the oven, every burner, the dishwasher and the garbage disposal.
- Check the water heater: no leaks, no rust at the base, the relief valve isn't dripping.
- Run one load in the washer and dryer if they come with the house. Clean the dryer vent all the way to the outside.
- Replace the HVAC filter. Run the AC or heat long enough to feel it working.
- Run every faucet and flush every toilet. Look under each sink for drips and soft cabinet floors.
- Try every lock, window latch, sliding door and gate.
Mold and moisture: dark corners of the laundry room, bathroom tile and caulk, closets on exterior walls, under sinks.
Surfaces: patch and touch up walls, check flooring for damage, professionally clean windows if needed, steam-clean carpets.
Outside: landscaping trimmed and weeded, irrigation running, trash bins present, house numbers visible.
Locks: rekey or replace the locks for every tenancy. Keep a key log: how many keys, garage remotes, mailbox keys and pool or gate keys went out, so you know exactly what to collect back.
Cleaning: a full move-in clean of the kitchen (inside appliances and cabinets), bathrooms, floors, windows and sills, fans and vents. The checklist download has a room-by-room list.
Photos: once it's clean, take dated photos and a walk-through video of every room, every appliance, and the yard. These become your move-in condition record.
Federal rule, everywhere: if the house was built before 1978, you must give every new tenant a lead-based paint disclosure and the EPA pamphlet Protect Your Family From Lead in Your Home before they sign. You can get both free from the EPA's lead disclosure page.
Setting the rent
- Pull comparable rents for the same bedroom and bath count within about a mile. We use Rentometer plus active Zillow and Apartments.com listings.
- Price at fair market minus $50 to $100. The point is to have at least two qualified applicant groups to choose from, not to squeeze out the last dollar.
- Decide the extras up front and write them in the listing: pet rent, which utilities the tenant pays, who handles the yard, whether HOA dues are included.
- If you have no qualified applications after about two weeks of showings, lower the price. One empty month usually costs more than a year of a slightly lower rent.
The listing
Have this ready before you post:
- Bedrooms, bathrooms, square feet, property type (house, duplex, apartment)
- Rent, deposit, pet rent, application fee, and which utilities the tenant pays
- Appliances included (washer and dryer?), parking, yard, pool, laundry
- What's nearby: schools, grocery, hospital, parks, bus line
- 15 to 25 good photos. Lead with the best room and the outside. Order matters: people decide from the first three.
- Your qualification criteria, written out (see Applicant Screening). Putting them in the listing saves you dozens of calls from people who don't qualify.
Post it everywhere it's free or cheap. We use Zillow Rental Manager (which also feeds Trulia and HotPads), Apartments.com, Facebook Marketplace, and our own website. Use the same text and criteria everywhere.
Every listing reply gets the same first answer: it's available, here are the requirements, and send your name, phone number and email so we can call you to set up a tour. The Listing Template download has the listing text and the reply messages.
Showing an occupied house
If the current tenant is still living there, showings need their cooperation and proper notice.
- Tell them the showing windows as early as you can, ideally a week ahead. Group showings into a few windows rather than scattering them through the week.
- They don't have to be home. Suggest they put away valuables and personal items.
- Say thank you. A tenant who cooperates with showings is doing you a favor, and it's worth mentioning in their reference.