Chapter 10
Ending a Tenancy Early and Evictions
Every way a tenancy ends before its time: back-outs, early termination, non-renewal, cash for keys, and eviction as the last resort.
Key takeaways
- An eviction is the most expensive way to end a tenancy, for both sides. Try an agreement first.
- Cash for keys (paying a tenant to leave by a date, with a signed agreement) is often cheaper and faster than going to court.
- Never self-help. No lock changes, utility shut-offs or removing belongings, except through a court writ carried out by an officer.
- Every notice is checked against the ledger and the law before it goes out. Mistakes restart the clock.
- Offer a realistic payment plan in exchange for a move-out date. A tenant who can actually pay is more likely to pay.
Before anything in this chapter, read the ground rules in Tenant Problems. Everything here has legal consequences, and the rules vary a lot by state. Talk to an attorney before you file anything.
An applicant backs out after signing
It happens: someone signs, then finds another place or has a change in their life.
- Confirm the facts: everyone signed, the start date, whether they took possession, what they've paid.
- Call them first, to understand what happened. Don't threaten.
- Explain the real cost to you, briefly: you turned away other applicants and have to start marketing again.
- Offer a written mutual cancellation. Ours asks for about one week's rent to cover the re-listing, and both sides release each other. Put the amount, the release, what happens to anything they've paid, and the signatures in writing.
- Re-list the home the same day, and keep a record of your marketing.
Early termination by agreement
Covered in Tenant Problems. Use the Early Termination Agreement download, check first for legally protected reasons (military orders, domestic violence and others), and re-market the home right away.
Not renewing
You can usually decline to renew at the end of a lease term, as long as you give the notice your lease and state law require, and the reason isn't discriminatory or retaliatory.
- Check the lease end date and the notice period the lease and law require. Calendar it well ahead.
- Serve the written notice with proof of delivery.
- Keep everything else normal until move-out: rent collection, repairs, respectful communication.
- Follow Move-Out and the Security Deposit.
Cash for keys
When a tenancy has gone wrong (unpaid rent, constant conflict), offering money for a clean, quick move-out often beats court on cost, time and stress.
- Agree on a move-out date (usually 1–3 weeks out), the condition the home is left in, the keys returned, and a payment to the tenant, paid only when they hand over the keys and the home is empty.
- Put it in a signed agreement, including what happens to the deposit and any balance owed.
- On the day: inspect, collect the keys, pay as agreed, and both sign a short statement that the agreement was fulfilled.
Eviction
An eviction is the last step, after reminders, conversations and the proper notice.
Before filing
- The right notice, delivered right. Nonpayment, a lease violation, a health-and-safety problem, or an immediate-termination breach each has its own notice and waiting period (see Rent Collection and Tenant Problems). Deliver it as the law allows and keep the proof.
- Recheck the ledger the day before filing. If the tenant paid in full within the cure period, there's no case.
- Turn off partial payments for that tenant in your rent app once the notice is out. Accepting a partial payment after notice can complicate your case in some states; ask your attorney.
- Assemble the file: the lease and addenda, the ledger, every notice with proof of delivery, messages, photos, inspection reports, police or animal-control reports, and earlier warnings.
- Hire an attorney, or at least read the court's instructions for landlords. Send them the file. They file the complaint, and the court sets a hearing date.
Court
- Attend every hearing, on time, with the file organized and copies for the judge.
- Save the hearing notice, minute entry and judgment to the tenant's folder.
- If the tenant pays and the dispute is resolved before the hearing, follow the court's rules for dismissing the case.
Settling for a move-out. Even with a judgment, an agreement can be better than a lockout. What we've done: calculate the total owed, waive the late fees and pet fees, and spread the rest over a long, affordable payment plan (we've used 36 months) starting a month after they move out, in exchange for leaving by a set date. Put it in writing and calendar the date.
If they don't leave
If the tenant is still there after the agreed date or the date in the judgment:
- Ask the court for the writ of restitution (the court order to return the home to you), as soon as you're allowed to.
- The court sends it to the constable or sheriff, who schedules the lockout. Buy new locks before the day.
- On the day, meet the officer at the property. Only the officer removes the occupants.
- While the officer is still there, change the locks on every exterior door.
- Video the whole home.
- Handle belongings under your state's rules (see Move-Out and the Security Deposit). Tell the former tenant how and when to arrange pickup, and calendar the deadline.
- When they collect their things, do and sign the move-out inspection. Then send the deposit statement.